
How Does One Employee Injury Raise a Nursing Home's Workers' Comp Costs for Three Years?
How Does One Employee Injury Raise a Nursing Home's Workers' Comp Costs for Three Years?
Every administrator in skilled nursing and assisted living knows resident transfers are where staff get hurt. A recent Texas appeals decision puts a price tag on what happens when one goes wrong, and it's a good excuse to talk about the part of workers' compensation most operators never look at closely: the experience mod.
What happened in the Texas case
According to McKnight's Long-Term Care News, a Texas appeals court this month upheld most of a $7.1 million award to a certified nursing assistant who was hurt on the job at a nursing and rehabilitation facility in Pasadena, Texas.
The facts the court relied on are uncomfortable for any operator. The CNA had five years of experience but had been at this facility only three weeks. She had received one day of floor orientation instead of the facility's standard three. She testified she was told to move a resident weighing more than 300 pounds from a bed to a wheelchair by herself, even though other staff and supervisors agreed the resident needed a two-person transfer. During the move, the wheelchair brakes let go, the resident fell onto her leg, and she suffered knee, neck and back injuries.
Here's the unusual part. Texas is the one state that lets private employers opt out of the workers' comp system entirely. This facility had. Without a comp policy, the employee could sue her employer for negligence, and opted-out employers in Texas lose many of the defenses they would normally have. The appeals court upheld the negligence findings and the impairment awards. It did reduce one piece, future medical expenses, from the $500,000 requested to about $235,551.
Why this still matters if you operate outside Texas
In West Virginia, Pennsylvania, North Carolina, Ohio and the other states where we work, workers' comp is mandatory for most employers. That's a good thing. Comp is a trade: the injured employee gets medical care and wage replacement without having to prove fault, and in exchange the employer is generally protected from being sued for negligence. A seven-figure jury verdict like this one would be very unlikely for the same injury here.
But "covered by comp" doesn't mean "free." The same knee injury at a skilled nursing facility, personal care home or memory care community in a mandatory state still lands on your loss history, and your loss history drives your experience modification factor for years.
The experience mod, in plain English
The experience modification factor, or "e-mod," is a multiplier applied to your workers' comp premium. It compares your actual claims to what's expected for a business of your size in your industry.
A 1.00 mod means you're average.
A 0.85 mod means you pay 15% less than average.
A 1.25 mod means you pay 25% more.
The mod is usually calculated from three years of claims, typically excluding the most recent year. So one bad claim year can follow you through three renewals. And the formula is built to weigh how often you have claims more heavily than how large they are. A string of smaller lost-time injuries can hurt your mod more than one big one.
Quick math: on a $100,000 comp premium, a 1.25 mod costs you an extra $25,000 a year. Over the three years that claim stays in your mod, that's $75,000, and senior care margins don't have room for it.
My honest take: return-to-work is the best tool you're not using
The fastest way to turn a manageable injury into an expensive one is to send a hurt CNA home for 12 weeks. Lost-time claims pay wage benefits on top of medical bills, they're more likely to draw an attorney, and they tend to stay open longer.
A written return-to-work (light-duty) program changes that. If the doctor allows modified work, the employee comes back right away doing tasks like answering call lights, restocking supplies, helping with feeding, or running activities. That does three things:
- It can keep a claim medical-only. In most states, medical-only claims count for much less in the mod calculation than lost-time claims.
- Employees who stay connected to work and coworkers are far less likely to hire a lawyer.
- You keep a trained person on the floor instead of paying overtime or agency rates to replace them.
And the cheapest claim is the one that never happens. In this case, the facility's own standards (three days of orientation and two-person transfers for heavy residents) weren't followed. Policies only protect you when they're enforced every shift.
Questions to ask about your workers' comp program
1. What is your current experience mod, and which claims are driving it? Ask your agent for the actual rating worksheet, not just the number.
2. Are any of those claims still open with reserves that look too high? Reserves count against you until the claim closes, so it's worth asking the carrier to review them before your mod is calculated.
3. Do you have a written return-to-work program with a list of real light-duty tasks, and do supervisors know how to use it?
4. Do you track transfer-related injuries, and do you have enough lift equipment and staff to require two-person transfers when a care plan calls for one?
5. Is new-hire orientation actually completed before someone works alone on the floor, and is that documented?
The bottom line
Texas is an outlier, and most of our clients will never face a negligence suit from their own CNA. But they will face the slower, quieter cost of a high mod. The operators who keep comp costs down aren't lucky. They train, they enforce transfer protocols, and they bring injured people back to work fast.
If you run an assisted living, skilled nursing, memory care, personal care home or behavioral health facility and don't know your mod or what's behind it, our healthcare team at Centurion Insurance Services can walk you through it. Call me directly at 304.993.8393.
Source: McKnight's Long-Term Care News, "$7.1M verdict upheld in nursing home case resulting from lack of workers comp," November 12, 2026.
https://www.mcknights.com/news/7-1m-verdict-upheld-in-nursing-home-case-resulting-from-lack-of-workers-comp/
This article is for general information only. It is not legal advice and does not change the terms of any policy. Coverage depends on actual policy language and the facts of each claim.
